Every list in setup/packages/ is annotated -- which package exists for which
settings page, why an exception was made -- and install-packages passed the whole
file to dnf, comment lines included.
dnf does not ignore an argument it cannot match. It reports "No match for
argument: #" and exits 1, and with set -euo pipefail at the top of that script
the first annotated list ends the stage. initial-packages carries four comments
and is the first list read, so a fresh machine got the repositories, the group
updates, and then nothing.
Two things hid it. On a machine that already has everything, a re-run matches
every real name and fails only on the comments, so the failure looks like noise
rather than the stage dying. And every contract that reads these lists strips
comments with sed before comparing -- the tests were reading a file the installer
was not, which is why a repository with a dependency contract, an assets contract
and a doctor still reported PASS across the board.
The fix is one filter used at all five call sites. The contract lifts that filter
out of the script and runs it, rather than describing what it should do, so
deleting or renaming it fails here instead of passing quietly. It also checks the
inverse -- that stripping comments does not strip packages -- because trading a
loud failure for a silent one would be worse than the bug.
Found while adding the extras lists for phase 4, which are annotated the same way
and would have hit the same wall.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NvgBuSWB5sE43yWmg21ozj
Helium was already declared. Podman Desktop is on Flathub, so it joins the
flatpak list beside the podman it fronts.
RustDesk was the interesting one. panama-doctor has checked `rustdesk.service`
for as long as it has existed, and autostart.lua works around the tray that
service spawns -- so RustDesk was already part of this desktop, installed by
nothing. The flatpak cannot register a root-owned system service, so unattended
access needs the RPM.
Claude Code has no RPM and no flatpak either, so it takes the official installer
and keeps itself updated afterwards.
Neither pins a version. sunhat pinned upscayl 2.11.5, LACT 0.5.4 and a fedora-40
RPM, and every one of those was a 404 within a release cycle; the RustDesk URL is
resolved from whatever the latest release happens to be. Both are skipped when
already present, and a failure is logged and stepped over rather than aborting a
stage that has already installed the desktop.
That leaves three exceptions to the dnf-or-flatpak rule, all named in one place
with a reason each. The dependency contract now knows they are installed out of
band, so probing for them with `command -v` is not read as an undeclared
dependency -- narrowly, per command, so a genuine omission still fails.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Q84axqUE5inJhf5Jz9CFy1
sunhat's failure mode was a question twenty minutes into a run. Walking away
from an install meant coming back to a prompt that had been waiting an hour.
So the questions move to the front. A new interview stage asks what Panama needs
to be told -- hostname, git identity, whether to sign in to GitHub, whether to
make an SSH key -- shows the answers back, and asks once to proceed. After that
nothing asks again. gum is bootstrapped before it runs, because the interview is
built on gum and gum arrives with a stage that has not run yet.
Answers reach the stages through a mktemp file that install sources and the
existing trap deletes, since a child process cannot export into its siblings.
They are not remembered between runs: there is no state file to go stale, and
one of the answers is an email address.
The interview asks only what a stage in this repository actually consumes.
Extras, hardware and debloat questions arrive with the stages that act on them
-- a prompt whose answer nothing reads is a control that lies. The new contract
pins that in both directions, and four deliberate mutations confirmed it catches
a question nobody reads, a stage reading something nobody asks, an answers file
left on disk, and a declined interview that fails to stop the run.
The run now ends with panama-doctor, because a failed-stage count says nothing
about a service that did not start. It never changes the exit code: on a fresh
machine, unconfigured is the honest answer, not a failure.
espanso and oh-my-posh stop being exceptions -- Terra packages espanso-wayland
and Fedora packages oh-my-posh, so the curl installer is gone. bun is now the
only remaining one.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Q84axqUE5inJhf5Jz9CFy1
The initial package list was quoted into a single bogus dnf argument
and every dnf error was discarded, so a fresh install silently skipped
most of it. Two package lists were never wired into the pipeline at
all, and change-settings ran before install-packages, so the vicinae
theme step was permanently skipped. Fixed the ordering, the quoting,
and stopped swallowing errors.
Separately, hypridle could start with its WAYLAND_DISPLAY condition
unmet if it raced the env-publish call, silently never starting --
and it's the only listener for the logind Lock signal. Made the start
wait on the environment synchronously. panama-idle also wrote its
generated config to a fixed temp path with no locking, so concurrent
applies could interleave into a corrupt file; switched to mktemp plus
an atomic mv.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01E6TJUAh41HaP25MVHWkhRZ
Gabriel Brown
gib